Did Amy Schumer steal from Patrice O'Neal?

Highly inspired · 60% similar · 2007 → 2015

Amy SchumerPatrice O'Neal

Made-up sex position names

Amy Schumer , compared with Patrice O'Neal

Highly inspired#33

The comic describes absurd, gross sex acts and gives each one a mock-official name.

Their versionAmy Schumer

Schumer runs through outlandish acts she calls "The Abe Lincoln" and "The Houdini." (paraphrase)

Live at the Apollo (HBO), 2015▶ watch ↗

The originalPatrice O'Neal

O'Neal's set featured named acts including "The Gorilla Mask" and "The Poltergeist." (paraphrase)

The Nasty Show, Just for Laughs Montreal, 2007▶ watch ↗

Why they're similar60%

Same format of naming gross sex acts like official moves, but every name and payoff on record is different.

  • Premise 34/40
  • Structure 18/30
  • Punchline 8/30
  • Premise34/40Same device: describe gross, absurd sex acts and give each a mock-official name.
  • Structure18/30Both run a list format, act described then named, repeated.
  • Punchline8/30The names differ entirely: Abe Lincoln and Houdini versus Gorilla Mask and Poltergeist.
Beat by beat
Amy SchumerPatrice O'Neal

Setup

She describes outlandish, gross sex acts.

=same

Setup

He describes absurd, gross sex acts.

Turn

Each act gets a mock-official name.

=same

Turn

Each act gets a mock-official name.

Punchline

Names like The Abe Lincoln and The Houdini.

≠different

Punchline

Names like The Gorilla Mask and The Poltergeist.

Scores and beats are our editorial reading of the public record, not a ruling.

Context

When and where

O'Neal performed his sex-position names at Just for Laughs Montreal's Nasty Show in 2007. Schumer's version is in Live at the Apollo (HBO, 2015). The comparison spread in October 2015.

What followed

Reddit users raised the comparison in 2015 (the linked video shows both clips side by side). Schumer, who had co-hosted a radio show with O'Neal, said she loved him and had never seen him do those jokes.

Photos via Wikimedia Commons: Amy Schumer by Mario Santor, CC BY-SA 3.0; Patrice O'Neal by King Taco, CC BY 2.0

Every case links to public reporting. These are accusations and the record around them, not rulings. Bit descriptions are paraphrases, never transcripts.

All 45 cases