Did Carlos Mencia steal from George Lopez?

Highly inspired · 66% similar · earlier → later

Carlos MenciaGL

The Taco Bell joke

Carlos Mencia , compared with George Lopez

Highly inspired#29

A Latino comic's joke built around Taco Bell, which George Lopez says Mencia took for his HBO special.

Their versionCarlos Mencia

Lopez has said Mencia's HBO special contained about 13 minutes of his material; the Taco Bell joke is the only bit he has named publicly. (paraphrase)

HBO stand-up special (as cited by Lopez)find on YouTube ↗

The originalGeorge Lopez

Lopez claims the joke as his own. Comic Ted Sarnowski says he did it on radio in 1988, that Lopez used it without permission, and that he explicitly let Mencia perform it. (paraphrase)

Stand-up actfind on YouTube ↗

Why they're similar66%

Everyone involved calls it the same Taco Bell joke, but no wording survives on record, and even its original author is disputed.

  • Premise 30/40
  • Structure 18/30
  • Punchline 18/30
  • Premise30/40Both sides call it the same Taco Bell joke, but its content is not on record.
  • Structure18/30Claimed to be the same joke; no text exists on record to compare its shape.
  • Punchline18/30No version of the punchline is on record for Mencia, Lopez or Sarnowski.
Beat by beat
Carlos MenciaGeorge Lopez

Setup

A joke built around Taco Bell, in his HBO special.

=same

Setup

A Taco Bell joke, claimed by Lopez and by Sarnowski.

Turn

Not on record.

?no record

Turn

Not on record.

Punchline

Not on record.

?no record

Punchline

Not on record.

Scores and beats are our editorial reading of the public record, not a ruling.

Context

When and where

George Lopez said on The Howard Stern Show that Mencia used about 13 minutes of his material, including a Taco Bell joke, on Mencia's HBO special. Comedian Ted Sarnowski says the joke was his: he performed it on radio in 1988, where Lopez was the station's resident comic.

What followed

On The Howard Stern Show, Lopez said he got physical with Mencia over it. Sarnowski's counterclaim muddied who originated the joke, and Mencia has denied stealing from Lopez.

Photos via Wikimedia Commons: Carlos Mencia by Sara Csurilla, U.S. Air Force, Public domain

Every case links to public reporting. These are accusations and the record around them, not rulings. Bit descriptions are paraphrases, never transcripts.

All 45 cases