Did Grant Denyer steal from Matty Johns?

Stolen · 89% similar · 2017 → 2017

Grant DenyerMatty Johns

Showing a 10-year-old the board game Test Match

Grant Denyer , compared with Matty Johns

Stolen#13

An adult proudly introduces a modern kid to the old cricket board game Test Match, and the kid is deeply unimpressed by the technology.

Their versionGrant Denyer

Denyer told the story on air as something that happened to him. (paraphrase)

The Kyle & Jackie O Show (KIIS FM), 2017find on YouTube ↗

The originalMatty Johns

Johns had told the anecdote to Denyer, who'd also appeared as a guest on Triple M's show. (paraphrase)

The Grill Team (Triple M), 2017find on YouTube ↗

Why they're similar89%

Denyer retold Johns's Test Match story as his own; the anecdote is the same, only the person it happened to changed.

  • Premise 39/40
  • Structure 26/30
  • Punchline 24/30
  • Premise39/40Same anecdote: an adult shows a 10-year-old the old Test Match board game.
  • Structure26/30Same story beats, retold by Denyer as his own experience after hearing it from Johns.
  • Punchline24/30Both land on the kid being unimpressed; exact wording of either telling is not on record.
Beat by beat
Grant DenyerMatty Johns

Setup

He proudly shows a 10-year-old the board game Test Match

=same

Setup

Johns shows a 10-year-old the board game Test Match

Turn

The kid is unimpressed by the old technology

=same

Turn

The kid is unimpressed by the old technology

Punchline

Told as his own story; exact payoff line not on record

?no record

Punchline

Johns's own story; exact payoff line not on record

Scores and beats are our editorial reading of the public record, not a ruling.

Context

When and where

In January 2017 Grant Denyer guested on both Triple M's The Grill Team and KIIS's Kyle & Jackie O Show. On Kyle & Jackie O he told a story about introducing a 10-year-old to the board game Test Match, which turned out to be Matty Johns's story.

What followed

Kyle & Jackie O phoned the rival Grill Team live on air to get to the bottom of it, and both shows jokingly 'banned' Denyer.

Photos via Wikimedia Commons: Grant Denyer by Eva Rinaldi, CC BY-SA 2.0; Matty Johns by https://www.flickr.com/photos/radar286/, CC BY 2.0

Every case links to public reporting. These are accusations and the record around them, not rulings. Bit descriptions are paraphrases, never transcripts.

All 45 cases